Anti-Zionism is simply a coded attack on Jews, shrouded in politics and politically correct language.
Anyone with an accurate understanding of anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism as concepts will understand they are different. One is bigotry, one is a political difference of opinion.
Because anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic rhetoric is identical, both are damaging for the Jewish community.
The same people spreading anti-Zionist thought are likely to be the same people harbouring anti-Semitic views.
Racists are not the same as segregationists. But the same people who are racist are often segregationists and the segregationists are also often racists. They may not be linguistically the same, or apply to identical contexts, but the same people subscribe to both.
Anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism functions in the same way. The two concepts may not be identical, but both go hand-in-hand. Anti-Semites are often also anti-Zionists, and anti-Zionists also often subscribe to anti-Semitic views.
This is empirically false. While racism is an essential component of segregationist thinking, anti-Semitism is not an inherent part of anti-Zionism. This is evident in the many Jews who do not subscribe to Zionism and the anti-Semites who embrace Zionism. Also, just because a group that subscribes to one view is predisposed to another view doesn't mean that both views are dangerous. If it turned out that 99% of convicted war criminals love apples, that wouldn't make apples dangerous.
[P1] Many anti-Semites are also anti-Zionists. [P2] Therefore, both are dangerous to society.
[Rejecting P2] Just because a group holds one dangerous belief, doesn't mean all that group's beliefs are dangerous.
Sign up or log in to record your thoughts on this argument